A successful film is a complete story. A successful franchise is a revenue stream. These two things are often incompatible, which is why we have seventeen Fast & Furious films and counting.

Some franchises justified their continuation. Most didn't. These ones definitely didn't.

Pirates of the Caribbean (Stop after 1, maybe 3)

The Curse of the Black Pearl is a perfectly contained adventure. It has a complete arc, satisfying conclusion, and never needed a sequel. But it made $654 million, so sequels were inevitable.

Dead Man's Chest and At World's End expanded the mythology into incomprehensible nonsense involving Davy Jones, Calypso, and pirate politics that nobody asked about. They made billions anyway.

On Stranger Tides and Dead Men Tell No Tales are films that exist. Johnny Depp collected paychecks. The magic was long gone. A sixth film is apparently in development, because nothing stops until the revenue does.

The Matrix (Stop after 1)

The original Matrix is a masterpiece with a definitive ending: Neo flies away, having achieved his potential. Perfect.

Reloaded and Revolutions complicated the elegant original with Zion politics, rave sequences, and increasingly incoherent philosophy. The Architect scene is a masterclass in saying nothing with many words.

Resurrections (2021) exists as a meta-commentary on sequel culture while itself being an unnecessary sequel. The irony was intentional. It still didn't justify the film's existence.

The Matrix worked because it was singular. Everything after was footnote.

Jaws (Stop after 1)

Spielberg created a perfect blockbuster. The sequels were made without him and it shows.

Jaws 2: Same beach, different shark. Fine.

Jaws 3-D: The shark attacks SeaWorld. The 3D was the point.

Jaws: The Revenge: The shark follows the Brody family to the Bahamas. The shark has a vendetta. The shark roars despite being a fish. Michael Caine couldn't attend his Oscar ceremony because he was filming this. He later said he'd never seen it but had "seen the house it built."

The franchise is a case study in diminishing returns, both artistic and commercial.

The Terminator (Stop after 2)

Terminator 2 is one of the greatest action films ever made. Its ending - the T-800 lowering into molten steel, thumbs up - is a perfect conclusion. Sarah and John survived. Skynet was prevented. Story over.

Every sequel since has had to undo T2's ending to exist. Rise of the Machines said judgment day was inevitable. Salvation showed the war. Genisys rebooted the timeline. Dark Fate killed John Connor in the first scene.

The franchise keeps trying to recapture T2's magic by contradicting its themes. You can't make a sequel to "we prevented the apocalypse" without un-preventing it. The sequels are structurally self-defeating.

Alien (Stop after 2, maybe)

Alien is horror perfection. Aliens is action perfection. Both are complete films that function beautifully alone or together.

Alien 3 killed Hicks and Newt off-screen, invalidating Aliens' emotional journey. Fincher was destroyed by the production. It has defenders but it wasn't necessary.

Resurrection has underwater xenomorphs and a weird Ripley clone. Prometheus is a prequel about different things. Covenant can't decide if it's a sequel to Prometheus or a prequel to Alien.

The franchise has spent 30 years trying to recapture lightning. It hasn't worked.

Shrek (Stop after 2)

Shrek is a sharp fairy tale satire. Shrek 2 is arguably better, expanding the world and characters while maintaining the wit.

Shrek the Third is a slog. Shrek Forever After is a contractual obligation. The spinoffs range from acceptable (Puss in Boots) to forgettable.

The franchise went from subverting animated film conventions to becoming exactly the product it originally mocked. There's a lesson in there about success corrupting satire.

Indiana Jones (Stop after 3)

Raiders through Last Crusade form a perfect trilogy. Indy rides into the sunset. Done.

Kingdom of the Crystal Skull brought him back at 65 to fight CGI aliens while surviving a nuclear blast in a refrigerator. The film was a study in how not to revive a franchise.

Dial of Destiny brought him back again at 80. The results were predictably mixed. Sometimes characters should stay retired.

The Pattern

Successful franchises don't stop because they've told their stories. They stop when the money stops. And the money usually doesn't stop until long after the creative justification has.

Every unnecessary sequel dilutes the originals. Every mediocre entry makes the franchise less special. The ones that work - Mad Max: Fury Road, Top Gun: Maverick - are exceptions that prove how rare successful long-gap revivals are.

The lesson Hollywood refuses to learn: sometimes done is done.

Test Your Film Knowledge

Related Articles